The Lineup
Maureen Mackey
January 8, 2009, 07:12 AM Fiction or Nonfiction? The Sequel By Maureen Mackey

    This morning I read (again in The New York Times) that Herman Rosenblat's Holocaust story may now be published as fiction, this coming spring.

    An independent book publisher based in Westchester County, New York—York House Press—is in discussions with Rosenblat about releasing his book as fiction.

    On this publisher's website is a rather eloquent statement that shares their thoughts on the matter.

    It says, in part:

    "York House Press is in serious discussion to publish a work of fiction in early spring that is based on the screenplay, tentatively called Flower at The Fence, about Herman Rosenblat’s life and love story, that is grounded in fact and that rises to the proper levels of artistic value, ethical conduct and social responsibility."

    To read their full explanation and statement on their site, click here.  

    Smart move? To my mind, yes--published as fiction. It makes what is an apparently compelling narrative available but clearly lays out what is what.

    No one is denying that Mr. Rosenblat suffered a terrible fate and had huge injustices done to him. His concentration-camp imprisonment has been verified by historical records. One's heart goes out to him and his family. 

    But people simply want to know what is truth and what is not, and what they can believe.

    We'll stick with this story, follow its ever-winding threads, and report back.

     

     

     

     

     

Share Your Comments
Name
Comment
Remaining Character Count:
 
By kwhistory, 01/08/2009, 11:44 PM EST
The memoir was pure fiction -- not just the angel by the fence portion but much of what Herman described as his experiences -- in Piotrkow, Buchenwald, and Schlieben. This was not a function of what he endured but of what he hoped to gain.
By oljoe49, 01/08/2009, 10:59 PM EST
IF THIS STORY IS PUBLISHED, I HOPE THAT THE FORWARD IN THE BOOK STATES VERY CLEARLY THAT ITS FICTION. IT AMAZES ME THAT SOMEONE WOULD LIE ABOUT SOMETHING LIKE THIS, BUT IT WAS MORE THAN LIKELY A COPING MECHANISM OF SOME KIND FOR THIS PERSON AFTER ALL THEY HAVE ENDURED. THANKS JOE
By momdeb2, 01/08/2009, 10:46 PM EST
Even if this story is published as fiction, its still a touching story that will be sure to make people think of the good that can be found in others. Fiction or not.
About This Blog

The Lineup is our blog of lists that cover topics like health, money, career and books. Written by Reader's Digest editors and guest experts, The Lineup will give you great advice you can use in your daily life.


Advertisement
Archive