Print | Close X

Comparing Flat Roof Vents And Turbine Vents

Choosing the right roof vents to cool the house in summer and prevent ice dams in winter


Q  I’ve hired a roofer to replace my shingles. He’s planning to tear off all the shingles and replace all the roof vents and flashing. Here’s my question. He wants to replace the wind-driven whirligig-style roof vents with flat roof vents, saying they’ll handle the venting just as well and look better. Am I getting taken? (I know the flat ones are cheaper.) If they’re just as good, I’m happy since I’m sick of hearing the old ones squeak all the time.

A  All things being equal, wind-driven turbine vents do move more air than flat vents (but only when the wind blows). The question: How much air must be moved? A largely arbitrary rule of thumb that’s been adopted into most building codes calls for 1 sq. ft. of vented area for every 300 sq. ft. of attic space. So a 1,500-sq.-ft. attic must have 5 sq. ft. of vent space-half dedicated for air intake in the soffits and the other half for exhaust on the roof. (These can be ridge vents, wind turbines or the flat vents your roofer wants to install.)

Good attic ventilation is important for preventing ice dams in the winter. It also keeps your home cooler in the summer, vents moisture that finds its way from the living spaces of your home into the attic and helps shingles last longer. The fact is, it’s hard to overventilate an attic. Generally, more is better.


If you don’t like the looks of wind turbines, don’t be afraid to use the flat vents; just be sure to follow the 300-sq.-ft. rule. But if you want to use wind turbines, buy high quality ones that have permanently lubricated ball bearings or plastic bushings in the spinning mechanisms. Usually, it’s the cheaper units with metal bushings that will squeak and eventually drive you (and your neighbors) out of your mind on windy nights.


Comments :
By Glen Pappas, 02/02/2010, 3:19 PM EST

Referring to Oct 2000, Comparing Flat Roof Vents And Turbine Vents, specifically the portion that says, "... most building codes calls for 1 sq. ft. of vented area for every 300 sq. ft. of attic space ...," how mahy square feet of vented area do you get credit for with a turbine vent?

Print | Close X