Buying a Healthy Butter Substitute

Shopping tips from the American Dietetic Association.

By Janis Graham from Reader's Digest | December 2008
Buying Butter Substitutesclipart.comBe a smarter spread shopper!

Finding the best one depends on what you’re looking for, says Constance Brown-Riggs, an American Dietetic Association spokesperson, who offers these guidelines:

  • If you want the smoothest buttery taste, look for labels that say original or regular. Both varieties have up to 9 grams of fat per tablespoon (almost as much as butter’s 11 grams), which is why they mimic the real thing. But their mix of poly- and monounsaturated fats is much better for your heart than the saturated fat in butter.
  • If you’re worried about your waistline, opt for light tubs or sticks made from blended oils like canola, olive, or soybean. At about 50 calories a tablespoon (versus 102 in butter), they’re the best lower-calorie option for good taste and texture. While fat-free spreads have just 5 to 20 calories a tablespoon, their high water content makes them less satisfying, so you may use more.
  • If you’re concerned about high cholesterol, look for products labeled with added plant sterols, extracts shown to cut bad LDL.
  • If you want to cook with it, check for the warning “not recommended for frying or baking.” Then make sure the label doesn’t say hydrogenated, a red flag for trans fats, which are still in some margarines and stick spreads.

Want to stay smart and healthy?

Get our weekly Health Reads newsletter

Sending Message
how we use your e-mail