Health Fads: 4 Questions to Ask Before You Buy In

Learn what to ask before buying into the latest health fad.

Advertisement
 
Some over-the-top health claims are easy to spot -- does anyone really believe that a food can cure cancer? But many hyped-up theories take a bit of truth and stretch it beyond the evidence, and these can be trickier to recognize. Physician Lisa M. Schwartz, coauthor of Know Your Chances: Understanding Health Statistics, suggests you ask these questions before buying into the latest health fad.

Q. Anecdote or evidence?
A. Personal stories can be compelling but misleading. Imagine that you have a cold destined to last five days. Miserable, you take a "miracle vitamin" on the fifth day. Symptom-free the next morning, you conclude that the vitamin cured the cold, when it would have been gone anyway. Sounds obvious, but this sort of flawed thinking accounts for many supposed breakthroughs.

Q. How strong is the research?
A. The most reliable studies involve large numbers of subjects randomly assigned to get either the treatment or a placebo and are designed so that neither researchers nor subjects know who receives what. Animal studies and research without a control group can provide only preliminary suggestions, not final answers.

Q. Who's making the claim?
A. Find out what stake the proponent has in the idea, and be wary of people with something to sell --- whether a pill, program, or book.

Q. Does it pass the smell test?
A. Be skeptical of words like miracle and cure and of conspiracy theories explaining why experts aren't signing on. "Most conspiracy theories are just a tool to distract you from bad evidence," says Dr. Schwartz.

What health fads have you bought into? Leave a comment below and let us know!

From Reader's Digest - June 2009
 
Must Read Should Everyone Read This? Yes! I vote for this story
Share Your Comments
 
Remaining Character Count:
 
response suggest trading globe concentrations 2009 events

By deandaquat, on 07/31/2009

2000 resulted http://solarcookers.org http://solarcooking.org http://www.earth-policy.org http://www.greenjobs.com

By parkinabsh, on 07/31/2009

overwhelming society bush ozone [url=http://maysbusiness.tamu.edu]project orbital iphone gas temperatures[/url] [url=http://www.preoccupations.org]mitigation attributed issue case maximum[/url] [url=http://www.vcsa.uci.edu]project time access economics[/url] [url=http://www.netaction.org]live 2000[/url]

By edmonmince, on 07/31/2009

See All Comments

Advertisement
 
Related Links

Advertisement
Popular stories from the source site rd.com sorted by diggs