6 Health Products That May Be a Waste of Money

From mouthwash to eyedrops, consider rethinking these medicine cabinet mainstays.

By Lauren Gelman
  • Loading


    If you brush, floss, and get regular pro cleanings, mouthwash is probably not necessary for your oral health, according to many dentists on ShareCare.com. “Most mouthwashes are only effective at the very surface,” noted Dante Gonzalez, DMD. "If plaque and bacteria are allowed to build up on the teeth and tissues, the mouthwash is not very effective at penetrating into the plaque.” Thomas Connelly, DDS, who said he is not crazy about mouthwash, also said that they do kill bacteria, but the effects don’t last very long. Also, the alcohol dries out your mouth, which can actually increase bacterial growth. If you do want to swish, pick a product that’s right for you—those with cavity-fighting fluoride, for example, aren’t great if you have gum disease. RealSimple.com offers a helpful primer if you need.

    Photo Inc/Getty Images

    Vitamin C

    Think megadoses of C will keep the common cold at bay? Mark Levine, MD, a researcher at the National Institute of Diabetes and Digestive and Kidney Diseases, told Reader’s Digest earlier this year that popping C supplements will basically just give you expensive urine. To get the health benefits of protection from cancer, heart disease, age-related macular degeneration, and more come, the best evidence comes from studies where people consume vitamin C naturally in their diets, not through supplements. Also important: “The body works very hard to absorb low amounts of vitamin C,” Dr. Levine says. “But as the dose goes up, you absorb much less, and you excrete the extra vitamin C through your urine in a matter of hours.”

    mediaphotos/Getty Images

    Expensive Sunscreen

    When it comes to protection against UV rays (responsible for skin cancer and wrinkles), you don’t always get what you pay for. In its 2013 review of sunscreens, Consumer Reports found that the least effective sunscreens were also the priciest. Of the top-rated sunscreens, three were generic store brands from Target, Walmart, and Walgreens, each costing less than $1.67 per ounce. Nearly all dermatologists acknowledge that we are not good at applying sunscreen properly, which greatly diminishes its protective abilities. That might change if you buy sunscreen that you can afford to apply liberally and often—ideally every two or three hours during a day at the beach.

    Image Source/Getty Images

    Cotton Swabs for Ears

    “Buy Q-Tips if you want to make your ear doctor rich,” Stephen Rothstein, MD, a clinical associate professor at NYU in the department of otolaryngology, said his grandmother used to tell him. Wax may look and feel nasty, but resist the urge to scoop it out with a swab. For one thing, your body makes the wax for a reason: It works as a lubricant, defends against foreign objects, and even has antimicrobial properties. Cotton swabs can push the wax too far into the ear canal, where it can harden and create a blockage—and that may affect your hearing.

    SelectStock/Getty Images

    Eyedrops for Redness

    You may turn to these when you wake up looking like a zombie, but experts advise against using eyedrops regularly. Mark Melrose, an emergency physician and owner of Urgent Care Manhattan, told USNews.com that they can mask a more serious underlying problem, like dry eye, allergies, or irritation from contact lenses. Eyedrops can even make matters worse, triggering persistent redness because your eyes can get used to them. If your eyes look bloodshot and irritated, first see a doctor to figure out if there’s an underlying issue, Melrose advised.


    Facial Toner

    There’s something satisfying about the squeaky-clean feeling you get after you swipe on toner, but it’s probably an unnecessary step in your beauty routine, dermatologist Doris Day, MD, told WomansDay.com. Newer soaps don’t leave the residue that toner was invented to remove, the article explains.


    Want to stay smart and healthy?

    Get our weekly Health Reads newsletter

    Sending Message
    how we use your e-mail

    Your Comments

    • Grace Brix

      Seriously, cotton buds? Oh please!

    • Sailesh Ghelani

      Pharma companies and hospitals don’t want you using some of these products like multi vitamins because then you’ll be healthy and they’ll lose out on future patients for their wards and expensive ‘life-saving’ drugs. A lot of these ‘studies’ are funded by them. And this has been told to me by a doctor!

    • Missy

      Actually, toner is meant to close the pores after the warm water used for washing the face opens them up. I took professional skin care classes, and the routine is: use warm water and mild soap or facial cleanser to open pores and wash away dirt and makeup, then use a toner that’s proper for your skin type to close the pores, and finally, use a moisturizer to keep the skin soft and help prevent wrinkles. Sea Breeze is not a toner, btw, it is an astringent, and only the oiliest skin can tolerate it.

    • Sandi

      Lauren: I have no teeth, and still use a small amount of mouthwash almost daily, especially if I’m headed out among the public. I don’t knot, it just makes the mouth feel better, and maybe freshen the breath a bit.

    • happygolucky112

      I feel a cold coming on and pop a 1000 of vitamin c
      Next day I feel much better – call it subliminal or whatever

      IT WORKS!!!!

      obviously we all agree that these doctors are whacked!

    • dangdang

      you need an eyedrops, and it works everytime for me! say no to doctor! and mouthwash is very useful too.

      • Jennifer Cross

        They were talking about eyedrops for redness, which is not good for your eyes. Eyedrops for moisture are good.

    • Nadya

      I love my mouthwash :( may be I want to waste money on it!! Huh!

    • Nina Dee

      This is contradicting to what my dentist said. I have braces, and she specifically told me to make sure that I use a mouthwash after brushing.

    • Lauren

      What if you have no teeth I like to use mouthwash for a good cleaning.