Quick Study: Voting Machines

Do voting machines work as well as they should?

By Lisa Goff
From Reader's Digest
Advertisement
 
Image
Here we are at the dawn of the 21st century, the height of the Information Age, mere months before a major election, and Americans still aren't sure that their votes will be recorded the way they cast them.

Much of the uncertainty involves the rapid conversion in the last decade from paper ballots to computer voting, or "e-voting," which promised to be faster, cheaper, and less subject to human error. But after a flurry of election scandals and machine breakdowns, more than half of the states now require voting systems that leave a paper trail in case a recount is needed. Apoplectic champions of e-voting argue that human error and poll-worker shortages pose bigger threats than technical glitches and crazed hackers. In the end, it all comes down to voter confidence. (According to blackboxvoting.org, an avowed enemy of e-voting, voters in Maine, New Hampshire, and Wisconsin can be most confident. Those in Pennsylvania and Texas, on the other hand, have the most to worry about.)

The Help America Vote Act (HAVA) gave $3.9 billion to states in 2002 to help replace punch card and lever systems with optical-scanning or electronic (usually touch screen) systems. Cuyahoga County, Ohio, a flash point in the voting-machine controversy, spent $21 million to switch to touch screens in 2006. This year, it could spend up to $12 million to switch again, this time to optical scanners. Much of the country finds itself in the same predicament:

Do we have the right machines? Can we get the right machines in time for the next election? And do we even know for sure which machines are the most reliable?

When it comes to voting, America is still a nation divided. Thirty-three percent of us will vote on touch screens in November. Sixty percent will use paper ballots tabulated by optical scanners. But since the Holt bill-which would have reimbursed states for switching to paper-ballot voting systems-was recently defeated in Congress, Americans may find themselves doubting the democratic process once again. Protect your vote by confirming your voter registration; many states will be using centralized records for the first time. Better yet, volunteer as a poll worker. One of the few things e-voting fans and opponents agree on is that the best insurance for a fair election is an equal number of Democratic and Republican eyes watching the ballot box.
Must Read Should Everyone Read This? Yes! I vote for this story

Your Comments

See all

...

Post your comment

You will be asked to sign in or register to post a comment

Characters Remaining

If it ain't broke---why is it so important to fix it? You enter the voting place. Your voter ID is By HillbillyBill, on 08/17/2008

To the extent that one issue may be speed --everybody would like to hear the outcome of each electiBy MyNotion, on 05/21/2008

I just want my vote to count! I could care less if its computerized or if its on paper.By bbcookie, on 05/21/2008


Advertisement
 
Related Links
  • In Their Own Words
  • To gauge how today's youth will shape our upcoming election, Reader's Digest commissioned a poll that posed a broad range of questions about the political and personal views of young adults between the ages of 19 and 29.
  • About Our Survey
  • Find out more about how we conducted our poll of young voters in the 2008 election.

Advertisement