Socialized Medicine: A Brief Look at Misconceptions

What does socialized medicine really mean?

Advertisement
 
Medical Supplies
© 2009 Jupiterimages Corporation
What we're actually going to get is not socialized medicine or single-payer health care. It's a hybrid, and it will be uniquely American.
Image

The label of socialized medicine has killed many a proposal over the years, including Harry Truman's idea for national health insurance in the 1940s. Yet as Ezra Klein points out, the term's meaning eludes many speakers.


The words socialized medicine and single-payer health care get thrown around with such gleeful abandon that they've both become a bit unmoored from their actual meanings. In the American health-care debate, they tend to refer to "whatever the Democrats are proposing." But that's not what they mean.

Socialized medicine is a system in which the government owns the means of providing medicine. Britain's is an example of a socialized system, as is, in America, the Veterans Health Administration. In a socialized system, the government employs the doctors, owns the hospitals, and purchases the technology. I have literally never heard a proposalfor converting America to a socialized system of medicine.

Single payer is a system in which one institution purchases the care. But the payer does not own the doctors, hospitals, or MRI scanners. Medicare is an example of a mostly single-payer system.

What we're actually going to get is not socialized medicine or single-payer health care. It's a hybrid. Private insurers, hopefully competing with a public option. Private doctors and private hospitals. Government regulation and subsidies. It's going to be messy and inefficient and hopeful and the product of a mix of corporate preferences and public compassion and latent populism. It will, in other words, be a uniquely American system, and hard to describe with a single epithet.


Visit voices.washingtonpost.com/ezra-klein

From Reader's Digest - September 2009
 
Must Read Should Everyone Read This? Yes! I vote for this story
Share Your Comments
 
Remaining Character Count:
 
I will never feel safe with anyone involved in my health care who pays benefits. I want freedom from government in my matters. Is this pop control How can we pay for everyone to have full range of service? Frivolous suits make good Doctors do unnecessary tests Government is not the solution Indivduals holding people responsible are.Don't be fooled

By Anne Marie, on 09/06/2009

Tou can call it anything you please. The only thing that SCARES me is that its another government program. I would like to see the car bailout,stimulas packages and other government throw aways work before we spend more money that we hope China will pay for we as a country are in far to deep as it is.

By Louis McKenna, on 08/17/2009

See All Comments

Advertisement
 
Related Links

Advertisement
Popular stories from the source site rd.com sorted by diggs