Yes, there’s a method to the madness … even when it’s annoying
I still remember the day I was flying solo with a toddler and an infant—right as the baby unleashed an epic diaper blowout at 30,000 feet. Somewhere over Kansas, I found myself fashioning a makeshift diaper out of a borrowed Pull-Up and safety pins. (They say necessity is the mother of invention, but let’s be real: Mothers are the original inventors.) The toddler was … as helpful as you’d expect. And the woman I borrowed the Pull-Up from definitely thought I was the world’s most unprepared mom.
But I swear I wasn’t! The problem was that my carefully packed carry-on—stuffed with diapers, snacks, toys and what felt like a full pediatric pharmacy—had been gate-checked. I remember watching it roll away from the jet bridge and trying not to panic while the gate agent assured me this was necessary because there was “no more room in the overhead bins.”
Except when I boarded, the bins were as empty as my will to travel with small children. And this was not a one-time occurrence. Flight attendants and airport agents will often feed you this line when there’s clearly room in those overhead bins. We can see it with our own eyes, people, so what the heck is going on here?
To find out, I talked with two travel experts who’ve spent more time at the airport than I’ve spent searching for toddlers’ missing socks: Kristine Eksteine-Nizka, a flight attendant and travel writer, and Pietro Lanzarini, a former airline station manager and the founder of a baggage tracking startup. Their answers will make you double-check your bag—and your assumptions. Read on to get to the bottom of this airplane annoyance (and maybe be a little less annoyed in the end).
Get Reader’s Digest’s Read Up newsletter for more travel, tech, cleaning, humor and fun facts all week long.
Do airlines ask you to gate-check bags when there are weight issues with the plane?
Nope. Despite what your conspiracy theory–loving seatmate may whisper, it’s not about weight. “Weight and balance issues aren’t a factor for carry-ons,” Eksteine-Nizka says, adding that she checked with her husband, airline pilot Michal Nizky, to confirm. “Cabin bags are included in the passenger’s weight. It doesn’t really matter that much where it’s stored.”
Lanzarini agrees: “There are never weight issues. Airlines use standardized weights for passengers and their bags in their load calculations.” Interestingly, the latest FAA standards, as of 2021, assume an average adult passenger weight to be 190 pounds in the summer and 195 pounds in the winter—carry-on included.
So that’s one myth grounded. But if it’s not about weight, then …
Why do they do this when there’s still overhead space available?
Turns out, it’s not about the space you see—it’s about the space they expect to be filled. “It’s often about speeding up boarding or enforcing policy early,” Lanzarini says. “On a full flight, if everyone brings a carry-on, there’s just not enough room. So airlines start checking bags early, even if the bins still look empty.”
Eksteine-Nizka adds that bag-checking decisions are often made before passengers board. “Sometimes it’s just a time-saving move. It’s faster to check a few bags at the gate than have people arguing over space in the aisle. And if your bag is too big or you brought too many, it may have to go under—rules are rules.”
When do they usually make this request?
Basically, whenever the flight is packed, delayed or the gate crew is doing mental travel calculus. “The senior flight attendant or gate agents will assess whether there’s likely to be enough space based on how full the flight is, the route and even the type of travelers,” Eksteine-Nizka explains. “There are trends.”
What kind of trends? Glad you asked:
- Holiday flights: People often travel with gifts, which means way more bags.
- Work travel routes: Some routes popular with certain travelers can mean more cabin bags. For example, offshore workers in Norway are notorious for overpacking their carry-ons, according to Eksteine-Nizka.
- Tour groups: Many tour packages include checked luggage, which means fewer cabin bags.
- Overstuffed boarding area: If the gate workers see that the waiting area is full of bags, they’ll immediately see it will be necessary to gate-check some of those bags.
Lanzarini also says that if there’s a delay, gate-checking is one way to speed things up: “Fewer carry-ons means faster boarding. It’s just logistics.”
So don’t take it personally—it’s not about you. It’s about all of us. And our packing habits.
What else might prompt a request for you to gate-check your bag?
Our experts share there are a few common triggers that will get your bag gate-checked—most commonly things that happen because you didn’t follow the carry-on rules.
- Your bag is too big or bulky. (The overhead bins have weight and size limits on them, so the size limits are not arbitrary.)
- You brought more than the allowed number of items.
- You’re on a smaller aircraft with limited cabin space.
What should you do if you really don’t want to gate-check your bag?
First, try to board early. According to Eksteine-Nizka, “If a passenger sees that the flight is full, arriving early to board is the best bet.” You’re more likely to score bin space if you’re not in the final boarding group playing overhead-bin musical chairs. And this was probably my mistake when flying with my kids. I’d waited until the very end to board, trying to minimize the time I had to entertain them on the plane, and by that point, the overhead bins were all spoken for (if not visibly filled).
Other smart moves:
- Stick to size limits. If your bag fits the airline’s specs, you’re more likely to be allowed to keep it.
- Speak up about your needs. Eksteine-Nizka says if your carry-on has medicine, health gear or electronics inside, make sure to tell the gate agent. “Never, ever check medicine,” she warns. “Checked bags can’t be reached during the flight.”
- Pack a backup mini-bag. “One thing passengers can do is have a tiny foldable daypack,” Eksteine-Nizka suggests. That way, you can quickly pull out essentials if you’re forced to gate-check. (This is what I should have done in the diaper scenario!)
- Be nice. Honestly, it never hurts.
One thing not to do? Keep your passport in your carry-on. If your carry-on gets gate-checked and your connecting flight is in another terminal or country, you’re out of luck. Even if that’s not the case, you’re also in for a world of hurt if your luggage is delayed or goes MIA.
Where do you pick up your bag after it’s been gate-checked?
Upon landing, there are three possibilities to be reunited with your bags:
- Baggage claim, along with the rest of the checked bags.
- Plane-side pickup.
- Right at the door where they bring it to you as you disembark. This is relatively rare, but it’s how I got my diaper bag and stroller back.
“Most gate-checked bags end up with the rest of the checked luggage at baggage claim,” Eksteine-Nizka says. “But sometimes—especially on smaller planes or when boarding or disembarking directly from the tarmac—you might get your bag right outside the plane.”
Lanzarini adds that this depends on the airport and aircraft. “Bridge boarding may prevent aircraft-side returns. But walking boardings often allow it.”
So now you know: Gate-checking bags isn’t a scam, it’s a strategy—even when it looks like there are plenty of open spots. Sure, it’s frustrating when you know you packed like a minimalist ninja only to watch your bag get spirited away. But gate-checking is rarely arbitrary. It’s a carefully choreographed dance of efficiency, safety and avoiding complete overhead-bin chaos.
RELATED:
- Here’s Why Flight Attendants Pay Attention to Your Shoes
- Here’s Why Flight Attendants Always Sit on Their Hands During Takeoff and Landing
- Here’s Why So Many Flight Attendants Wear Red Lipstick
About the experts
|
Why trust us
Reader’s Digest has published hundreds of travel stories that help readers explore the world safely, easily and affordably. We regularly cover topics such as the best places to visit (and the best times to visit them), tips and tricks to zoom through airport security, flight-attendant secrets, hotel-room hacks and more. We’re committed to producing high-quality content by writers with expertise and experience in their field in consultation with relevant, qualified experts. We rely on reputable primary sources, including government and professional organizations and academic institutions as well as our writers’ personal experiences where appropriate. We verify all facts and data, back them with credible sourcing and revisit them over time to ensure they remain accurate and up to date. Read more about our team, our contributors and our editorial policies.
Sources:
- Kristine Eksteine Nizka, flight attendant and travel writer for Love Your Italy; email interview, July 29, 2025
- Pietro Lanzarini, founder of Traxit and former airline station manager; email interview, July 29, 2025
- AirInsight: “The pending new FAA Weight & Balance rules”
