It's not hard to make restaurant quality mashed potatoes at home!
I’ve worked in professional kitchens. I’ve cooked Thanksgiving dinners for a hundred people. I’ve written about food for decades. And yet? Mashed potatoes still have the power to humble me if I’m not giving them the attention they deserve. They’re a dish that literally anyone can make. (For real! It’s not hard to boil a potato till mushy, then mash the dickens out of it.) But if you’re not taking things seriously, your mashed potatoes won’t taste nearly as good as the ones you get at a restaurant.
Restaurant mashed potatoes are richer, smoother and somehow more comforting, like a velvet blanket of butter and salt. As Chef Dylan Gaydos of the Townley House Hotel and Restaurant in Easton, Pennsylvania, puts it: “Restaurants have access to top-quality ingredients, professional-grade cookware and years of perfected technique.”
I’m not alone in my obsession. In fact, our America the Tasty named mashed potatoes the signature comfort food in two states—including Idaho (naturally). But honestly? Mashed potatoes are quite possibly the signature comfort food of America, period. So let’s solve this mystery together. Why do restaurant mashed potatoes always taste better, and how can you channel a little of that chef magic at home? Read on to find out the secrets.
Get Reader’s Digest’s Read Up newsletter for more food, cleaning, humor, travel, tech and fun facts all week long.
Why do mashed potatoes taste better at a restaurant?
The short answer: technique, ingredients and a fearless—borderline reckless—approach to butter. The long answer? Let’s break it down. Here’s what restaurants do to get that perfect mash:
Pick the right potato
Restaurant chefs aren’t winging it here—there are spuds that are meant to be mashed! Others have no business being anything but roasted. The gold standard for mashed potatoes are starchy potatoes like Russets, because they cook fluffy and light.
Waxy spuds such as red-skinned, fingerling and new potatoes produce a final mashed potato that tastes like paste, so save those for other uses. Popular Yukon Golds fall somewhere in the middle. They won’t give you the perfectly creamy mash an Idaho Russet might, but you’ll still get a fantastic finished product.
Boil with the skin on
Save yourself some time and skip the peeling! Simmering potatoes with the skins on keeps them from getting waterlogged, which means the flavor stays concentrated. Once peeled and mashed, you’ll notice the taste is creamier, almost buttery—before the butter even hits the bowl.
Respect the tools
I’ll tell you as a chef: your choice of tool is half the battle.
“Never put them in a blender,” warns Gaydos. “Over-mixing releases too much starch, leaving the potatoes gummy and with an undesirable texture.”
Restaurants turn to potato ricers and food mills when it comes time to mash their spuds. Why? They break potatoes down evenly without overworking them. If you don’t have a ricer or food mill, use a hand masher, or an electric mixer set to low speed.
Season boldly
I can’t stress this enough—season your potatoes at every stage. Salt the water before boiling, taste as you mash and don’t be shy when reaching for the butter dish.
“Butter is the cornerstone of that rich, velvety flavor,” says Gaydos, and he’s right. Many chefs also fold in heavy cream, sour cream or even cream cheese for extra tang and richness.
Know when to stop
In cooking, restraint is a skill. With mashed potatoes, the less you fuss, the better. Overmashing is how you end up with something closer to wallpaper paste than dinner-party-worthy potatoes. A few passes with a ricer or masher, and you’re done!
What’s the easiest way to up your mashed-potato game at home?
You don’t need a restaurant kitchen to make better mashed potatoes—you just need good technique. Start with Russets or Yukon Golds, boil them skin-on and drain well before mashing. Use a hand masher or ricer, season generously and never forget the butter. Lots of butter, lots and lots of butter.
“Don’t be afraid to experiment,” Gaydos advises. “Research different methods, try new seasonings, and adjust along the way. The best results often come from learning through trial and error.”
As for add-ins? I’m a big fan. America the Tasty highlights Maine’s signature comfort food: lobster mashed potatoes, which I can vouch for as decadence on a plate. But you don’t need lobster to get creative. Fold in roasted garlic, cheddar and scallions, caramelized onions or even a drizzle of flavored oil.
What’s the one thing you should never do with your mashed potatoes?
Repeat after me: no blenders, no food processors. That’s how you end up with gummy, gluey potatoes no amount of gravy can save. “Stick with a hand masher, ricer or food mill for the best results,” says Gaydos. Overworking potatoes is the single biggest mistake home cooks make.
So yes, mashed potatoes at restaurants might have a little extra sparkle thanks to pro gear and heavy-handed butter usage, but you can get surprisingly close at home. Trust your potatoes, trust your tools and trust the butter. Because when it comes to mashed potatoes, more is more—and that’s exactly the point.
About the expert
|
Why trust us
At Reader’s Digest, we’re committed to producing high-quality content by writers with expertise and experience in their field in consultation with relevant, qualified experts. We rely on reputable primary sources, including government and professional organizations and academic institutions as well as our writers’ personal experiences where appropriate. We verify all facts and data, back them with credible sourcing and revisit them over time to ensure they remain accurate and up to date. Read more about our team, our contributors and our editorial policies.
Source:
- Dylan Gaydos, chef at Townley House Hotel in Easton, Pennsylvania, interviewed, August 2025
