You Be the Judge

This Family’s Christmas Display Was So Extravagant, the City Called It a Hazard

Should the Hyatts be forced to limit or even shut down their holiday 
display? You be the judge.

december-01-VV-YBTJNoma Bar for Reader's Digest

It’s no surprise that the Hyatt family of Plantation, Florida, calls its annual holiday display Hyatt Extreme Christmas. Ever since 2006, on the day after Thanksgiving, Kathy and Mark Hyatt and their two kids have unveiled the full spectacle: more than 200,000 lights, a 30-foot Christmas tree, a 20-foot Ferris wheel, a 20-foot inflatable movie screen that shows Disney movies on a loop, life-size ginger­bread men, blowing snow, a giant Nativity scene, Santa’s workshop, a Christmas countdown sign, and live animals, including a “reindeer” horse named Yofi—all packed onto the 
Hyatts’ just-under-an-acre lot.

The display takes three months to assemble and attracts approximately 2,000 visitors each holiday season. It is lit Sunday through Thursday from 6 to 10 p.m. and until 11 p.m. on 
Fridays and Saturdays, and it all stays up until December 28, when every­thing gets packed away for the next year. Some neighbors on the cul-de-sac the ­Hyatts share with seven other large homes move temporarily to avoid the five weeks of what one described as a “nightmare” of litter, blocked driveways, and the din of nonstop caroling and jingle-belling. (Here’s how you should handle neighbors who don’t take down their Christmas lights.)

december-01-VV-YBTJTatiana Ayazo/Rd.com

The city, though, has been most concerned about safety. When there’s no available parking on the cul-de-sac, visitors walk to the ­Hyatts’ after parking around the corner on Old Hiatus Road, a dimly lit two-lane street with no crosswalks. Plantation’s police department has tried over the years to make the area safer when the display is all merry and bright. For example, in 2013, the department paid overtime for two 
officers to control the traffic on a busy weekend and also created a “safe zone” for pedestrians on Old Hiatus, blocking off nonresidential traffic on a stretch of the road. But despite No Parking signs, visitors continued to park there.

In February 2014, the city filed a complaint in circuit court. It claimed that the display’s “carnival-like 
atmosphere” was a public nuisance, since it posed a public-safety threat. It asked the court to order the Hyatts “to refrain from promoting, erecting, and operating a holiday display at their residence of a nature, extravagance, or size [that attracts] large numbers of the public.”

But attracting the public is the point. As the family explains on its website, “The Hyatts love this time 
of the year as it give[s] us an opportunity to spread ‘Joy’ and ‘Holiday Wishes’ to so many people.”

Should the Hyatts be forced to limit or even shut down their holiday 
display? You be the judge.

The Verdict

No. A four-day trial was held in September 2016, and Judge Marina Garcia-Wood ruled a month later that the display itself didn’t threaten public safety. “There was no testimony or evidence that the Hyatts utilize their property 
in such a way that results in injury … of the City or to its residents,” she wrote. Further, she concluded that traffic congestion was “being exacerbated by the City and the City’s police department safety zones, not the Hyatts.” 
So the Hyatts opened the gates in 2016 to much rejoicing. The ruling “almost brought me to my knees,” Mark Hyatt told the Sun Sentinel. For 2017, the ­Hyatts are, as Mark describes it, “taking our display to the next level.” They’re adding a fancy new movie-like projector to light up the one part of their house that has always remained dark—the windows. They’re adding a new feature outside too: Santa’s reindeer stables.

Become more interesting every week!

how we use your e-mail
We will use your email address to send you this newsletter. For more information please read our privacy policy.