You Be the Judge

Is the Owner of an Icy Sidewalk Responsible If You Fall and Get Injured?

A woman slips and falls after a big snowstorm. 
Is her apartment complex liable for nature’s handiwork?

JANUARY-2018-VV_YBTJ_US180242Noma Bar for Reader's Digest
The blizzard that pummeled northern Illinois and northwest ­Indiana on Groundhog Day in 2011 was a doozy. The National Weather Service declared it the third-worst winter storm in Chicago’s history. Outside the city, in the town of 
Carol Stream, Illinois, more than 20 inches of snow fell; five days 
later, the snow-removal service 
hired by the Klein Creek Condominium Association cleared all the 
sidewalks at the complex. The snow had mostly melted by February 18. Pamela Murphy-Hylton left her condo at 8:30 that sunny but below-freezing morning and walked along the sidewalk behind her building toward the parking lot. Next thing she knew, she’d fallen, fracturing 
her leg, knee, and hip. As she waited on the ground for the paramedics, she felt ice on the sidewalk. The patch was about the size of a sheet 
of paper.

Four months and several surgeries later, on June 13, Murphy-Hylton filed a negligence action in the 
Circuit Court of Cook County against the condominium association and 
its management company, alleging that “their negligent maintenance 
of the premises created an unnatural accumulation of ice, which caused her to fall.”

Three years later, on August 14, 2014, the trial court sided with the defendants and dismissed the case. Why? The owners of the complex were protected by the Illinois Snow and Ice Removal Act. The law 
states that property owners are not required to remove snow and ice 
because, basically, the weather there is too unpredictable for them to take 
on such an “unreasonable burden 
of vigilance.” While a property owner is “encouraged to clean the sidewalks,” according to the act, he or she is not liable if someone gets hurt by slipping and falling on “the snowy or icy condition.”

Nonetheless, Murphy-Hylton appealed to the Illinois Supreme Court.

JANUARY-2018-VV_YBTJ_US180242Noma Bar for Reader's Digest

The Verdict

Yes. Many municipalities (and some states) require property owners 
to remove snow and ice after a storm, but the regulations vary widely. However, Murphy-Hylton argued that this class of laws didn’t apply in 
her case. She said that the ice that felled her wasn’t from the snowstorm. 
Instead, it had allegedly formed when melting snow was funneled onto the sidewalk from poorly maintained drains and refroze there. The Illinois Supreme Court agreed with her, ruling that the state’s Snow and Ice Removal Act does not immunize owners when an icy sidewalk that causes 
an injury is due to a “negligent failure to maintain the premises.” That meant her case against Klein Creek and its management company could proceed. Attorneys are back in mediation to determine whether the complex is liable after all, and if so, what damages should be awarded.

Ice isn’t the only wintery occurrence that can cause serious harm. Look out for these other ways winter could actually kill you.

Become more interesting every week!

The Reader's Digest "Read Up" Newsletter

We will use your email address to send you this newsletter. For more information please read our privacy policy.