12 Best-Selling Cat Toys on Amazon—from a Pet Expert
Updated: Feb. 01, 2024
The best cat toys on Amazon are fun, affordable, and approved by our pet expert for supervised cat play and stimulation.
Our editors and experts handpick every product we feature. We may earn a commission from your purchases.
As a certified animal behavior consultant, I’ve seen many different personalities and toy preferences in cats. Because they play using stalk, chase, and bite behaviors, the ideal toys satisfy those natural needs. Here are all the best cat toys on Amazon, from interactive feather wands and jingle balls to catnip mice and cat tunnels, all designed to make your cat purr.
Cat Rainbow Wand Ribbons
Wand toys dance through the air or over the floor to mimic prey, and they’re a feline favorite. This Amazon’s Choice product, with 1,511 reviews averaging 4.5 stars, gets raves from pet parents and cats alike. It’s one of the best cat toys on Amazon. You get two wands with ribbons measuring 47 and 53 inches for interactive play at a distance—ideal for shy cats. You’ll love the bright rainbow colors, and cats enjoy the snake-like motion of slithery silk ribbons. I also love the company’s caution to always supervise ribbon toys so kitty doesn’t accidentally eat parts of the string-type material.
Flopping Fish Cat Toy
Another one of the best Amazon cat toys, and an Amazon Best Seller, this battery-powered Flopping Fish Cat Toy has a sensor that makes it flop when your cat touches it. You can choose from four fish shapes, each made with a soft, durable bite-able surface, and your cat can indulge his hunting instinct by stalking, pouncing, and chewing on the flopping toy. The rechargeable battery comes with an USB cable. With more than 36,000 ratings, this fish is the cat’s meow. Here’s another one with great ratings—this purring cat toy that’s amazing for de-stressing anxious kitties.
Cat Dancer
Cat Dancer has been around forever, and the simple toy-on-a-wire continues to delight felines. Yes, it’s cheap, but cats don’t care how much you spend. It’s highly recommended by veterinarians for its safety, and the company claims more than six million satisfied felines. With 29,500 ratings on Amazon averaging 4.6 stars, this toy will lure your cat over and over again. Here are even more Amazon pet products with nearly perfect reviews.
Cat Springs Indoor Toy
These brightly colored Cat Springs Toys are a hit with cats. The toy comes in two sizes, in a package of 10 springs, and it’s one of the least expensive of the best Amazon cat toys guaranteed to get cats chasing and pouncing. It has an Amazon average of 4.7 stars and 21,600 ratings. Cats paw-swat the lightweight springs and have a wonderful time chasing them across the floor. If they go missing, check under your appliances and couches—cats love to stash toys to fish out later.
Catnip Mouse Toys
Cats love lightweight toys they can send across the room with a paw swipe. They also enjoy soft plush toys to bite. Many cats react to catnip with fun, silly behaviors. Here’s an inexpensive Skitter Critters three-mouse set, with more than 30,000 ratings averaging 4.7 stars, that comes filled with potent catnip. I also love that SmartyKat toys meet child-safety standards, as there are no safety standards for pet toys.
Retractable Cat Wand Toy and Feather Teaser Refills
Does your cat wait by the window, chattering and watching birds flit outside? Feathers that replicate the look of birds rev up a cat’s prey drive and are one of the best cat toys on Amazon. With a feather lure on the end of a fishing pole string, you can make the imaginary bird fly, dive, and whirl to entice your cat to chase, leap, and catch the toy. An Amazon Best Seller, the MeoHui Cat Wand, has more than 21,500 ratings averaging 4.6 stars. It comes with two retractable wands and nine exchangeable feather or plush teasers. You’ll need the refills so you can let your cat catch and destroy the feathers—that’s part of the fun. Also, put the toys away when not in use, or cats may chew up and swallow pieces.
Cat Tunnel Tube
Scaredy-cats want hiding spots, but even courageous felines adore lurking in cat tunnels. It feeds into a cat’s instinct to stalk, lie in wait, and then pounce on prey (maybe your ankles) as you pass by. This popular, portable Collapsible Cat Tunnel incorporates a suspended ball to bat at and a hole in the center to peer out. It comes in four colors or patterns and is made from rugged polyester with a sturdy sprung steel frame. With more than 7,500 ratings averaging 4.6 stars, it’s earned an Amazon’s Choice designation. Even better, it has a 100 percent money-back guarantee.
UPSKY 3-Level Cat Roller Toy
Ranked a #1 Amazon Best Seller in cat toys, this UPSKY cat roller toy goes beyond the standard single ball-in-a-track. Four levels (three with balls) are detachable for easy cleaning, and so you can add or remove tracks and balls to keep cats engaged. Yes, plural—more than one cat can play at the same time. The toy has more than 38,400 ratings averaging 4.4 stars and comes in five cute colors, with three extra balls in case your genius cat extracts one. Cats won’t care about the fun colors, as Kitty sees mostly shades of green and blue, but you’ll love watching her play bat-the-ball in this cartoon-theme toy.
SmartyKat Electronic Sound Prey Toys for Cats & Kittens
We don’t like to think of cats catching a live critter. With SmartyKat Prey Toys, cats get what they want, and people don’t have to worry about their hunting exploits. The battery-powered toys in the shape of birds, mice, chipmunks, hummingbirds, and more make chirps, chatters, and hums to tempt cats into a fun game. These SmartyKat toys have more than 14,500 ratings averaging 4.5 stars. You’ll find the perfect critter to get your cat’s motor running.
Cat Laser Pointer Toy
One of the most popular cat toys, the laser pointer has pros and cons. Cats love chasing the light around the floor, up a wall, and all around the room. But keep it away from Kitty’s eyes to prevent injury, and take care to end the game by pointing the light on a physical toy. That way, the cat can complete the prey sequence by attacking and biting. Otherwise, laser games where your cat never “catches” the light prove frustrating and can lead to behavior issues. This Cat Laser Pointer Toy, ranked #1 in Amazon cat toys, has nearly 1,000 ratings averaging 4.6 stars. It has a rechargeable battery.
Mylar Crinkle Balls Cat Toys
With an average of 4.6 stars based on 5,439 ratings, Mylar Crinkle Balls tickle the fancy of kittens to adult cats. They’re light enough to bat around the room, they make fun crinkly sounds when bitten, and the light reflects off the shiny surfaces to entice the most sedentary feline. Buy these in bulk, because your cat will hide them everywhere, especially under appliances. They come in a six-pack, 12-pack, and 24-pack to keep even a large clowder satisfied.
Also find this cat toy at Walmart.
Petstages Dental Health Cat Toys
Yes, we struggle with cat behaviors that drive us nuts. We’re glad to have products that remove cat urine from carpet, for example. So finding toys that benefit a cat’s emotional and physical health makes pet parents happy! Don’t tell your cat, but playing with these Dental Health Cat Toys brushes their teeth when they bite and wrestle with them. They have more than 12,000 ratings averaging 4.2 stars, and you can choose from 10 unique designs. The toys are made with tough fabric streamers and durable pet-safe rubber (catnip infused) that encourages healthy chewing.
Originally Published: June 29, 2022
