Share on Facebook

The Very Best Diet for Cats, According to Vets

If you have a cat, you know that they can be picky about their food. Just don't try to make them a vegetarian! (It's actually bad for their health).

Every editorial product is independently selected, though we may be compensated or receive an affiliate commission if you buy something through our links.

Looking Down At Three Cats Eating From A BowlThorsten Nilson/EyeEm/Getty Images

Cats need lots of animal-based protein

“While there isn’t a single diet that is ideal for all cats, in general, most do best when they eat foods that are high in moisture and protein and relatively low in carbohydrates,” says Jennifer Coates, DVM, a veterinarian for Chewy. “A study published in 2011 showed that when cats are given access to foods of different protein, fat, and carbohydrate concentrations they tend to self-select a diet that provides them with around 52 percent of their calories from protein, 36 percent from fat, and 12 percent from carbohydrates.” Bottom line—there’s no such thing as a vegetarian cat. Along with feeding your cat the best food, you’ll also want to avoid these 12 common mistakes cat owners make.

Portrait of a tiny adorable kitten licking its lipsLisa5201/Getty Images

Age definitely matters

One of the most important factors to consider when shopping for cat food is your cat’s age. Different life stages mean different activity levels and nutritional needs. For example, kittens are generally far more active than their senior counterparts, and they also need additional nutrition to help them in their quick growing process. “Just as human babies don’t eat the same foods as adult humans, nor should kittens and adult cats eat the same foods since they require different nutrients as they change over the years,” says Brittany Carey, a cat specialist and manager at Cat Safari in San Francisco. “You may see cat food with the phrase ‘for all life stages’ in its description, but it’s best to seek life-stage nutrition.” We bet you never knew these things about your cat!

This high-quality kitten food is grain-free and made with real ingredients, like duck and turkey, and full of moisture and added vitamins and amino acids for a healthy immune system as they grow.

Shop Now

Cute persian cat eating dry food on white floorANURAK PONGPATIMET/Shutterstock

Your cats’ nutritional needs can vary over time

In addition to buying food according to your cat’s life stages, also consider any potential ailments or sensitivities they may acquire over time. For example, mother cats nursing their kittens require a much higher caloric diet, says the VCA, and some cats end up needing more simplistic diets due to allergies. Your vet can help you navigate these particular needs. These myths about cats are actually false.

Senior cats need food high in protein and moisture to support their renal systems while being lower in fat and calories to prevent weight gain, which can have adverse health consequences. For older indoor cats, this grain-free food is a great option.

Shop Now

Cute cat eating on floor at homeAfrica Studio/Shutterstock

Wet food just might be better

Though quality ultimately matters, in general, wet food is the superior option for cats when choosing between canned wet food and dry kibble. “Typically, wet foods meet a cat’s nutritional needs better than dry, but that may not be the case if the wet food in question is of very low quality,” Dr. Coates says. Just make sure you’re thoroughly cleaning your cat’s bowl between every wet food feeding, since it can be a harboring ground for bacteria, one of the ways it could be making your cat sick.

gray shorthair cat opening can with mouthWaitforlight/Getty Images

Beware of gimmicky labels

It makes sense that cat food brands want their product to stand out on the shelf, but be wary of gimmicky words such as “primitive,” “ancestral,” or “wild,” says Dr. Coates. “These terms are pure marketing. Instead of looking for flashy words, pet parents must look closely at a food’s label to determine whether it could be a good option.” Does your cat dream about living its most wild life? Find out what cats dream about.

Cute tabby cat lying on floor at homeAfrica Studio/Shutterstock

Cats should cool it on the carbs

As mentioned, cats are obligate carnivores that need high levels of animal-based proteins in their daily diet. Dr. Coates says, “Grains, and more generally carbohydrates, should only play a small role as a source of energy in a cat’s diet. Fillers are ingredients that serve no nutritional purpose and should be avoided.” Too many grains in a cat’s diet can lead to malnutrition, obesity, organ issues, and GI tract issues. It’s important to know the silent signs your cat is sick.

High Angle View Of Cat Looking At Food BowlThorsten Nilson/EyeEm/Getty Images

Look for the AAFCO statement

“Instead of sweating over the ingredient list, pay attention to the nutrients in your cat food,” says Carey. “Look for a statement from the Association of American Feed Control Officials (AAFCO) saying that the food is complete and balanced.” Do you know what your cat means when they make these noises?

This nutritionally-dense fish-based grain-free cat food is AAFCO-approved and a great all-around option for most adult cats.

Shop Now

ingredients for pet food holistic top view on wooden background279photo Studio/Shutterstock

Some human foods are OK occasionally

Though cats ought to stick primarily to packaged cat food, since it’s formulated specifically to their dietary needs, you can give them a nice treat periodically, such as tiny morsels of tasty human food. “Small pieces of cooked meat or fish make wonderful treats for cats,” says Dr. Coates. Other yummy treats include cooked egg, cantaloupe, and mashed sweet potato. Conversely, there’s a long list of human foods your cat cannot eat, including chocolate and grapes.

Little dog maltese and black and white cat eating food from a bowl in homeMonika Wisniewska/Shutterstock

Cats really shouldn’t eat dog food

At some point you might have wondered if cats can eat dog food—after all, they seem to look all the same—but the answer is not really. Dr. Coates says, “If your cat occasionally ‘steals’ a mouthful from your dog’s bowl, you have nothing to worry about, but make sure that 90 percent or more of your cat’s diet is made up of cat food.” This is because, as outlined above, cats rely heavily on diets rich in animal-based protein. Dogs have an entirely different set of dietary needs, and therefore their food is formulated according to their nutritional satisfaction. Learn more about the best diet for dogs.

Pouring pet food into a bowlRawpixel/Getty Images

Buy food in smaller quantities

Those 30 and 40-pound bags of dry kibble, or entire flats of cat food, may be enticing budget-wise, but they’re really intended for homes with multiple kitties. Aim for buying in quantities that can be used up in less than a month’s time, and ideally within three weeks. Find out the things you do that your cat secretly hates.

Young cat eating at home from its bowl. Female hand adding foodMilles Studio/Shutterstock

When and how you feed your cat matters

“Aside from the kind of food you’re feeding your feline friend, knowing how much you feed them and when are important factors, as well,” says Carey. “While it’s popular to ‘free-feed’ cats and let them graze throughout the day, most veterinarians recommend feeding set quantities at the same times daily. Free-feeding can easily lead to obesity which in turn can lead to more severe health issues like joint disease and diabetes.” This is how to understand your cat’s behavior.

cat treats, cat dietKoldunov Alexey/Shutterstock

Treats are exactly that—treats!

Cat treats, like human treats, are generally higher in calories and therefore ought to be given sparingly. The VCA website recommends using them strategically when training or curbing behaviors, or even as part of a bonding activity. If your cat ends up eating treats too often, it can disrupt their nutritional balance, impede their appetite for the food they really need, and can even cause them to become picky eaters. Do you know the signs your cat is happy?

cat overheadPixieMe/Shutterstock

Try making eating time more fun

In addition to needing meat, cats also do well when digging into their ancestral tendency to hunt for their food. There are a number of toys available that make eating feel like a game, like the Trixie Activity Strategy Game Tunnel Feeder Cat Toy and Doc & Phoebe’s Cat Co. Indoor Hunting Cat Feeder Kit. These are more tech gadgets every pet owner needs.

Closeup of two veterinarian doctors with stethoscope checking tabby cat's heart rate in clinic. PanoramaProstock-Studio/Getty Images

Your vet can help you figure out the best food for your cat

“We all know how fickle and opinionated cats can be, which can make finding the right food even more difficult,” says Carey. “Your best bet is consulting with your veterinarian to find the right balance of nutrients for your pet’s unique needs.” Not eating is one of the 15 signs your kitty is secretly mad at you.

Sources:

  • Jennifer Coates, DVM, veterinarian at Chewy
  • Journal of Experimental Biology: “Geometric analysis of macronutrient selection in the adult domestic cat, Felis catus
  • Brittany Carey, a cat specialist and manager at Cat Safari
  • VCA: “Feeding Your Cat Well – An Overview”

Wendy Rose Gould
Wendy Rose Gould is a freelance lifestyle reporter covering pets for Reader's Digest, Healthy Paws Pet Insurance, and Rescue Pop. She's also a regular contributor to NBC, Real Simple, Brides, Business Insider, and other outlets. Based in Phoenix, Arizona, by way of the Indiana countryside, Wendy holds a journalism degree from the Franklin College Pulliam School of Journalism and another bachelor's degree in Philosophy. Follow her on Instagram or Twitter @wendyrgould.