Share on Facebook

A Trusted Friend in a Complicated World

The Secret Ingredients Grandma Puts in Her Sugar Cookies

Amp up your baking game and make cookies that rival Grandma's! These added ingredients go way beyond an extra dash of vanilla: They'll have everyone asking for your secret recipe.

Freshly baked sugar cookies on cooling rack. Closeup with extremely shallow dof. ; Shutterstock ID 153370979; Job (TFH, TOH, RD, BNB, CWM, CM): Taste of HomeMarie C Fields/Shutterstock

There’s nothing better than a batch of sugar cookies. They always invoke childhood memories of the holidays or remind me of spending time in the kitchen with Grandma. She always had a few special ingredients up her sleeve that really made those cookies something special! Start with this classic sugar cookie recipe and add from there.

Mandarin zest on wooden board with couple of mandarins alongside; Shutterstock ID 554047369; Job (TFH, TOH, RD, BNB, CWM, CM): Taste of HomeRuslans Golenkovs/Shutterstock

Orange Zest

For a boost of flavor (and beautifully colorful addition), add a couple teaspoons of orange zest to your sugar cookies. They won’t taste overwhelmingly orange-like, but the zest adds some subtle pops of flavor as you eat the cookies. Just enough for people to wonder what your secret is! Orange zest transforms this holiday favorite, too.

Cinnamon sticks and cinnamon powder on wood; Shutterstock ID 646377511amphaiwan/Shutterstock


A dash of cinnamon adds a nice warming quality to sugar cookies, especially those made around the holidays. Go one step further and add some finely chopped pecans for a really flavorful punch.

Top view of a bowl and wooden spoons with dried and fresh lavender flowers and a bouquet of lavender on a wooden background ; Shutterstock ID 669397450; Job (TFH, TOH, RD, BNB, CWM, CM): Taste of HomeCora Mueller/Shutterstock


Adding a few teaspoons of dried lavender flowers is an elegant way to celebrate the simplicity of a sugar cookie. This recipe is perfect for the summer when all the flowers are in bloom!

A bottle of lemon essential oil on a wooden table, with lemons in the background; Shutterstock ID 753261424; Job (TFH, TOH, RD, BNB, CWM, CM): Taste of HomeMadeleine Steinbach/Shutterstock

Lemon Extract

A teaspoon of lemon extract adds the perfect amount of zesty lemon flavor to your sugar cookie. Extract is much more powerful than lemon zest, so you’ll only need half as much extract as zest for the same citrus flavor. Just look out for the 12 baking mistakes you didn’t know you were making.

Food Background with Close-up of Star Anise on Vintage Black Table. Selective Focus. ; Shutterstock ID 396111676; Job (TFH, TOH, RD, BNB, CWM, CM): Taste of HomeDG Stock/Shutterstock


Star anise has a mildly licorice-like flavor, but don’t worry—adding a pinch to your sugar cookies won’t make it taste like black licorice! It will be subtle: a hint of heat along with some subtly sweet after tones. Find out what is star anise anyway.

Homemade yogurt or sour cream in a rustic bowl; Shutterstock ID 369768824Fortyforks/Shutterstock

Sour Cream

Skip the cream of tartar and use tangy sour cream instead, like they do in this vintage sugar cookie recipe. If you’ve never used sour cream in baking before, you’ll be blown away at the soft, smooth texture of these cookies!

Sweet Almond Oil, first extraction, in a small glass jar, dry almond nuts on an old wooden background, selective focus; Shutterstock ID 386246191; Job (TFH, TOH, RD, BNB, CWM, CM): Taste of Home5PH/Shutterstock

Almond Extract

Add some depth and a nutty flavor to your sugar cookies by including a teaspoon of almond extract in the batter. After you frost the cookies, you can garnish them with sliced almonds to really punch that flavor home!

Rosemary bound on a wooden board; Shutterstock ID 567889069; Job (TFH, TOH, RD, BNB, CWM, CM): Taste of HomeNataliia K/Shutterstock


Give your sugar cookies a bit of a savory spin by adding fresh herbs. A teaspoon of finely chopped rosemary will add strong herbal aromas and a slightly piney flavor—perfect for a mid-afternoon snack! Here are more secret ingredients for irresistible cookies.

Homemade pumpkin pie spice in a glass jar with ingredients; Shutterstock ID 461456947Elena Veselova/Shutterstock

Pumpkin Pie Spice

These pumpkin latte-inspired sugar cookies are perfect for the fall (but really, I could eat them all year round!). A teaspoon of your favorite pumpkin pie spice will do the trick. Don’t think you have to pick up a store-bought spice—make your own at home!

Homemade salted caramel pieces on wooden background. Golden Butterscotch toffee candy caramels with copyspace.; Shutterstock ID 754713457; Job (TFH, TOH, RD, BNB, CWM, CM): Taste of HomeNatali Zakharova/Shutterstock

Butterscotch Flavor

Make your sugar cookies reminiscent of everyone’s favorite snickerdoodles without adding too much extra work. A drop or two of butterscotch flavor should do the trick! If you want to mimic this chai snickerdoodles recipe, add a pinch each of cinnamon, cardamom, and ginger, too.

Raw Organic Cardamom Pods Ready to Use - ancient ayurveda medicine and tasty spice; Shutterstock ID 551261716; Job (TFH, TOH, RD, BNB, CWM, CM): Taste of Homebarmalini/Shutterstock


Describing cardamom’s flavor is a bit tricky; it’s slightly spicy, slightly herbal, and a little bit sweet. It’s strong and aromatic and a little bit goes a long way, so you’ll only need less than a teaspoon to make this fun sugar cookie recipe.

Crushed peppermint candy cane bits sprinkled on wax paper backgroundbarmalini/Shutterstock


During the winter holidays, crush up some candy canes and add them to your sugar cookie batter. If you’re still craving that minty-fresh flavor later in the year, you can substitute peppermint extract instead. But, that means you won’t get that crunchy texture. Next, don’t miss these 15 other secret pantry ingredients that can make your recipes better.

Taste of Home
Originally Published on Taste of Home

Lindsay D. Mattison
Lindsay D. Mattison is a professional chef and a food writer. After graduating from Cascade Culinary school, Lindsay became the Executive Chef at Jackson's Corner in Bend, OR, from 2013 to 2016. Her genuine passion for food and sustainable food practices led her to find the farmer in herself. She lives in Durango, CO, where she enjoys the trials and errors of small plot farming. Lindsay is currently working on a cookbook that teaches home cooks how to craft beautiful meals without a recipe, tentatively titled "The Art of Bricolage: Cultivating Confidence and Creativity in the Kitchen."