Reader Digest Version Global

Who’s Right: Is Meat Good or Bad for You?

Fortified with vitamins or cause of cancer: Here's a lean lowdown on the latest studies to help you determine whether red meat is bad for you to eat.

By Chris Woolston from Reader's Digest Magazine | July/August 2012
Who’s Right: Is Meat Good or Bad for You?Andrew Scrivani/Getty Images

What You’ve Heard

Burgers, steaks, hot dogs—red meat is an American diet staple, but our carnivore cravings may be killing us. After tracking food choices of more than 121,000 adults for up to 28 years, Harvard researchers found that people who ate three ounces of red meat every day were about 13 percent more likely to die—often from heart disease or cancer—before the study ended than people who didn’t eat meat. And daily servings of processed meat such as bacon raised the risk of early death by 20 percent. Saturated fat and cholesterol are only the start of meat’s diet dangers. Overloads of iron can threaten the hearts of meat eaters; sodium and nitrates make processed meat even worse. It’s no wonder that many experts recommend reducing or eliminating red meat from your diet.

But Wait …

A 2012 report found that Americans who regularly eat lean beef get more protein, zinc, potassium, and B vitamins than people who don’t. And a 2010 report estimated that lean beef accounts for about 15 percent of the nation’s protein but only about 4 percent of total fat. “Lean meat is a healthy thing,” says Carol O’Neil, PhD, a coauthor of both reports and a professor of human nutrition and food at Louisiana State University.

So What Should You Do?

You can still fit a daily serving of red meat into a healthy diet. Choose lean cuts (see what the hosts of The Doctors TV suggest) and avoid processed meats (bacon, sausage, bologna—anything preserved with salt, curing, or chemicals). With fruits, vegetables, and whole grains to round things out, enjoying a steak isn’t a high-stakes gamble.

Your Comments

  • Emma A. Neill

    Thank you for all your very helpful articles and advice. I try to read most of them. God bless.
    Emma A. Neill

  • Hagar2935

    There’s a lot of information out there and sometimes it can be hard to tell fact from fiction when it comes to beef’s nutritional value. We’re setting the record straight on beef’s nutritional value and now you can learn the facts with our video series, Meat The Experts.
    Fact: Beef is an excellent source of protein, which helps support a healthy metabolism, and is a natural source of nine more essential nutrients including zinc, iron and B vitamins.Fact: Eating lean beef daily as part of a heart-healthy diet can help lower cholesterol. Check out the Beef in an Optimal Lean Diet (BOLD) study to learn more.Fact: There are more than 29 cuts of beef that meet government guidelines for lean and have a total fat content that falls between a skinless chicken breast and a skinless chicken thigh, when comparing cooked 3-oz. servings.

  • Hagar2935

    Not only does beef taste great, it is one of the best ways to fuel your body. Beef is a major contributor of  protein, zinc and vitamin B12, vitamin B6, iron and niacin. By supplying a nutrient bundle in every bite, eating beef is a great way to make the most of your calories. A 3 oz. serving of lean beef contributes less than 10% of the calories in a 2,000-calorie diet. At the same time, it supplies more than 10% of the Daily Value for these nutrients.
    And you have less likelihood to get DANGEROUS poisons from improperly processed and mishandled poultry!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • Hagar2935

    Not only does beef taste great, it is one of the best ways to fuel your body. Beef is a major contributor of  protein, zinc and vitamin B12, vitamin B6, iron and niacin. By supplying a nutrient bundle in every bite, eating beef is a great way to make the most of your calories. A 3 oz. serving of lean beef contributes less than 10% of the calories in a 2,000-calorie diet. At the same time, it supplies more than 10% of the Daily Value for these nutrients.
    And you have less likelihood to get DANGEROUS poisons from improperly processed and mishandled poultry!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • Ijazzzzzzzzzzz

    Yes but what about the effects on the planet of raising it?  What about all the grain it takes to feed it and could be used to feed people who are starving.  We certainly can’t feed them beef!  Just saying.
     

  • the magus

    you know something i can only say people sre always looking for ways to make a buch  or try to scare others ,but listen can i tell you drinking water is also a problem for your health  we are so bored that every year we find out something new so hey what ever you do,do it inmoderation,bless you all and enjoy the life you haveyou are the master of your future

  • Nell Buck

    I have been eating nothing but fruits and vegetables for two weeks! I can’t wait until I will be adding MEAT.  I have promised myself that I will be careful and not eat more than once a week. I think its a shame that something that tastes so good is bad for us.  My grandfather was a healthy 90 years and I can still see him eating “fat-back” (bacon) with his cup of hot water and two eggs each morning.

  • Calabaster4

    What is a non-processed breakfast meat to replace bacon or turkey sausage?

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1486315530 Arneson Tara

    I say, look at your family. If they are dying young and they all eat red meat, then cut back your self. Eat more vegetarian products and then have your meat only a couple times a week. Also when getting meat, look for grass fed organic beef. There are lots of local people who have farms where you can go out and pick out your own cow. Its much better for you than getting it from the store.

  • Anonymous

    Eating a BALANCED diet of lean meats (Beef, Pork, Poultry, or Lamb) means that you must include lots of vegetables and fruits. NOT JUST ONE THING! The human body was designed to consume a variety of foods and a good balance of the daily pyramid of foods is essential. It SHOULD include some red meats (Remember, PORTION CONTROL is important here). Yes Chicken can be a source of bad bacteria and chicken fat is just as bad for you as bacon fat, but if you cook ALL meats properly you can avoid most problems. Medium rare beef is usually safe, but most chicken must be well done. Pork should never be rare nor should lamb, but medium is still a safe level. Even seafood should be cooked a little bit…but be very careful to NOT overcook seafood however, because it not only destroys the flavor but some of the nutrients. Recent studies have also shown that dark meats of turkey can be especially healthy for you as well. 

    And REMEMBER……………… Moderation in all things is essential!

  • Bonerface2000

    @ Ijazzzz…

    Well, cows are actually herbivores and should not eat grains, they’re bad for them. In fact in order to remain alive on a grain diet they have to be pumped full of anti-biotics (also bad for them) otherwise they’ll die almost immediately.

    Second, grains aren’t exactly all that good for humans either, so we would be wise to do as cows do and eat leafy greens.

    Best to eat grass fed beef.

  • http://profile.yahoo.com/PSRWOF5RIKQTPSNRSVX3AUYHKA Jon

    Why do all the Independent studies show meat increases risk of dying, yet industry funded always give a different result? I’m sick of lobbyists and advertisers being the driving force being public information.

  • Jnuvoloni

    Ye sit is

  • Minecraftpronvm

    yes it is

  • Olivia

    That’s ridiculous to even consider meat being good for you! All of the nutrition in every sort of meat is contained in so many different types of foods. Don’t take the risks, and become a vegetarian! For you and for the animals. That way everyone is happy.

  • Kaitie

    All red meat is unhealthy. I have switched to just a fish and chicken diet. Saying beef has vitamins and is can do good for your body is a big lie. Modern medicine and doctors have proved the fact that meat can cause many diseases. I may even become a vegetarian, even though it would difficult to maintain the right amount of protein in my diet. I have a good friend who says since she’s become a vegetarian she feels much healthier and her doctor says she is. Her heart rate was increasing and she could have had a heart attack at the age of 27. Luckily, her doctor recommended to her a non-meat based diet. Now she’s healthier than ever! I’d love to live 10 more years, so I may follow in her footsteps.

  • veganguy

    If you have to eat it in moderation, it’s probably not good for you. Has anyone credible ever recommended that we eat our veggies and fruit in moderation?….J/s