This Is the Real Difference Between White, Cremini, and Portobello Mushrooms

Hint: It has to do with age!

Ah, mushrooms. The nutrient-filled fungi can be added to just about any dish, raw or cooked, and still taste delicious. (Seriously, mushrooms are just one of many healthy cancer-fighting foods.) With 10,000 different species of mushrooms discovered in North America alone and many more types left undiscovered, 90 percent of the United States consumes mushrooms of the agaricus bisporus family, according to Livestrong. In other words: cremini, white button, and Portobello mushrooms.

The difference between these three fungi depends solely on their age. The youngest variety of the agaricus bisporus family is the white button mushroom, also known as the table mushroom. These particular mushrooms are cultivated to be smooth and white for cooking; in the wild, their natural color tends to be more of a tinted brown. Although it falls behind its older siblings in terms of flavor, it is still the most ubiquitous of its kind, which makes it easy to utilize in almost any meal.

What-You-Never-Realized-About-Mushrooms-Until-Nowalicja neumiler/shutterstock

The cremini mushroom, also known as a baby bella, is the middle child to its younger white button and older portobello. At this stage, its brown color has developed, its flavor has intensified, its texture has firmed, and a sheath of skin should be covering its gills (if the skin is present then the mushroom is fresh). Want to cook something healthy but short on time? Try this Broccoli Rabe with Sautéed Cremini Mushrooms recipe.

The oldest version of the agaricus bisporus species is the portobello, also sometimes referred to as the open cap mushroom due to its open cap with visible, brown gills. It is purposely overgrown to achieve a more meat-like cap, which is commonly used as a meat-substitute. Throughout the overgrowing process, the portobello loses some of its moisture, resulting in it being a more flavorful version of its younger siblings. Less moisture is also more convenient for cooking, marinating, and grilling. (Keep these healthy grilling tips handy if you’ll be making some yummy grilled mushrooms anytime soon!)

Become more interesting every week!

Get our Read Up newsletter

how we use your e-mail
We will use your email address to send you this newsletter. For more information please read our privacy policy.