A Trusted Friend in a Complicated World

Your Favorite Christmas Cookie, According to Your Zodiac Sign

Updated: Feb. 27, 2023

The recipe for your holiday confection is written in the stars.

Your Favorite Cookie According To Your Sign
rd.com, Getty Images (3)

Cookies you can’t pass up

The true meaning of Christmas is bigger than trimming the tree, upstaging the neighbors with outdoor Christmas decorations, and hunting down the hottest Christmas toys—no matter what those Black Friday commercials try to tell you. And yet part of what makes the holiday so wonderful are the Christmas traditions involved, including baking a batch of your favorite Christmas cookies (or just eating everyone else’s homemade delights).

The question isn’t whether you’ll indulge in some holiday sweets. It’s how to choose among all the cookies clamoring for your attention. Sugar-sprinkled stars, decked-out gingerbread men, and peanut butter blossoms beckon for a tiny kiss under the mistletoe. But there’s a way to navigate the Christmas cookie quandary: Pick the holiday confection that aligns with your zodiac sign.

Just as you can discover your favorite fall cookie according to your zodiac sign and your favorite candy based on your zodiac sign, your ideal Christmas cookie can be found in the stars. We reached out to an astrology expert, who told us that each sign has its own preferences for flavors, sweetness, and ingredients. The stars can also guide you to the best way to celebrate the holidays for your zodiac sign, decorate according to the zodiac, and shop for zodiac-related gifts. But first, read about the Christmas cookie you’ll find sweet enough to steal from Santa.

Pfeffernusse Cookies Via Worldmarket
via worldmarket.com, Getty Images

Aries (March 21–April 19): Pfeffernusse

Daring Aries, whose signature flavor is black licorice, will enjoy the spicy and bold German pfeffernuss cookie, according to professional psychic and astrologer Stina Garbis. The chewy molasses and anise cookie is brimming with seasonal spices—think cinnamon, cloves, nutmeg, and even pepper. Rams’ zodiac sign element is fire, so warm and spicy are on their holiday menu. Garbis envisions Aries donned in a cranberry sweater, warming up by the fire with a pfeffernuss and a hot toddy.

Buy Pfeffernusse Cookies

Chocolate Chip Cookie Mix Via Williams Sonoma
via williams-sonoma.com, Getty Images

Taurus (April 20–May 20): Chocolate chip cookies

Taurus, the most sensual sign of the zodiac and a homebody, would use a mixture of fine chocolates and nuts to make the most decadent chocolate chip cookies, according to Garbis. “Nuts represent the earthy nature and flavor of this Earth sign. Plus, they add depth and crunch, which Taurus likes,” she says, noting that bulls would enjoy their cookie with red wine while wearing a luxurious robe or smoking jacket in a rich, jewel tone. Discover more about yourself by learning the best dog breed for your zodiac sign.

Buy Chocolate Chip Cookie Mix

Hershey Kisses Via Target
via target.com, Getty Images

Gemini (May 21–June 20): Peanut butter blossoms

With a dual nature and sweet tooth, Geminis crave cookies that combine more than one indulgence. “Peanut butter blossoms, with the Hershey kiss in the center, fit the bill for Gemini,” says Garbis. Gift the Gemini in your life a plate of homemade peanut butter blossoms, along with the best book for this zodiac sign.

Buy Hershey's Kisses

Whoopie Pie Tin Via Amazon
via amazon.com, Getty Images

Cancer (June 21–July 22): Whoopie pies

Cancers are soft and overly sweet, reminding you of your childhood. Their ideal cookie? The whoopie pie, according to Garbis. With its buttercream and marshmallow filling and soft cake rounds, the handheld sweet could be considered a cake. Garbis sees crabs curling up with a warm blanket and Christmas crafts, enjoying eggnog with their whoopie pies.

Shop Whoopie Pie Pans

Gingerbread Diy Kit Via Williams Sonoma
via williams-sonoma.com, Getty Images

Leo (July 23–August 22): Gingerbread cookies

Leos love taking center stage, and a well-decorated gingerbread man could help them do just that. The showy cookies remind lions of how special they are, according to Garbis, who sees Leos making batches of cookies and handing them out to all of their friends. Alternately, compile some gingerbread house ideas then go big and bold with an edible abode.

Buy a Gingerbread Cookie Kit

Danish Butter Cookies Via Amazon
via amazon.com, Getty Images

Virgo (August 23–September 22): Danish butter cookies

Virgo is organized, and so are their cookies. “A tin of assorted Danish butter cookies, given as a gift, satisfies their orderly nature while they express their love,” says Garbis. Virgos are health conscious, so they would choose a tin without preservatives or colors.

Buy Danish Butter Cookie Tin

Chocolate Chips Via Amazon
via amazon.com, Getty Images

Libra (September 23–October 22): Lace cookies with chocolate filling

Libra’s go-to cookie is just as lovely, sweet, and delicate as them. Lace cookies balanced with chocolate filling showcase this zodiac sign’s beautiful and harmonious nature, says Garbis.

Buy Chocolate Chips

Molasses Cookies Via Walmart
via Walmart.com, Getty Images

Scorpio (October 23–November 21): Molasses cookies

One of the most intelligent zodiac signs, the deep, intense Scorpio knows to reach for a comforting cookie. “Scorpios need a dark cookie that they can drown their sorrows in,'” says Garbis, who recommends a molasses cookie. Pair it with a brandy-based drink for the perfect holiday combo.

Buy Molasses Cookies

Snickerdoodle Cookie Mix Via Target
via target.com, Getty Images

Sagittarius (November 22–December 21): Snickerdoodles

With their bright, fun, and friendly attitudes, Sagittarians delight in a holiday favorite that brings cheer even when you say its name: snickerdoodle. Optimistic and spontaneous centaurs are fun holiday guests, Garbis says, and may want to wash down their cookies with a peppermint mocha. For more astrology fun, check out the ideal best friend for every zodiac sign.

Buy Snickerdoodle Mix

Oatmeal Raisin Cookie Mix Via Williams Sonoma
via williams-sonoma.com, Getty Images

Capricorn (December 22–January 19): Oatmeal raisin cookies

Earthy Capricorns love Christmas traditions, like biting into a deliciously old-fashioned cookie. Garbis sees the goat delighting in oatmeal raisin cookies made from a family recipe (and accompanied by a cold glass of milk).

Buy Oatmeal Raisin Cookie Mix

Orange Royals Shortbread Via Walmart
via Walmart.com, Getty Images

Aquarius (January 20–February 18): Chocolate and orange cookies

Aquarius is always unique and interesting. “The curious tang of a chocolate-and-orange cookie is right up their alley,” says Garbis. “They would pair it with a trendy turmeric drink or kombucha.” Looking for more dessert inspiration? Find the best Christmas cookie from every state.

Buy Chocolate-Orange Cookies

Sugar Cookie Set Via Williams Sonoma
via williams-sonoma.com, Getty Images

Pisces: (February 19–March 20): Sugar cookies

Pisces is sweet and sensitive and likes to reminisce. “Holiday sugar cookies, in fun shapes like snowmen and Santa, would make them very happy,” says Garbis. “But then they would feel bad about eating the poor snowman’s head and guilty for destroying such a cute work of art.” Keep learning how the stars can shape your life by learning the best hobby for your zodiac sign.

Buy a Christmas Sugar Cookies Set