Share on Facebook

A Trusted Friend in a Complicated World

The 9 Best Earrings for Sensitive Ears

Say goodbye to painful, red lobes with stylish earrings that are safe for even the most sensitive ears.

Every editorial product is independently selected, though we may be compensated or receive an affiliate commission if you buy something through our links. Ratings and prices are accurate and items are in stock as of time of publication.

Sensitive Earrings Opener RD.com, Via Retailers (3)

Many of us have been there: You spent the day shopping for the best accessories to help you update your style, and found the cutest pair of earrings. But then you tried them on at home, and your earlobes quickly got red and sore. Whether that’s always been the case or it’s a recent change, it’s almost certain that the metal in your earrings is to blame.

Having sensitive ears can make it hard to shop for affordable jewelry, since it’s often made with mixed metals that can cause allergic reactions. While you may have no trouble when it comes to buying elegant necklaces or cocktail rings, earrings can be tricky.

Luckily, you can find affordable, quality earrings to fill your jewelry organizer that won’t cause discomfort.

We asked Michele Green, MD, a board certified cosmetic dermatologist in New York City’s Upper East Side, to break down the exact causes of sensitive ears, why they can be problematic, and how to choose earrings that won’t cause pain and irritation. Read on to get the scoop and also find 10 pairs of great earrings that even the most sensitive ears can wear comfortably.

What makes ears sensitive?

When it comes to sensitive ears, a common form of eczema called contact allergic dermatitis is the culprit. This type of eczema is caused by direct contact with an allergen or irritant—in this case, the metal in your earrings. Dr. Green explains that when ears are pierced, the inner ear lobes have direct contact with the metals in earrings, which can be a source of this specific type of skin irritation. What’s more, the skin on your ears and earlobes is particularly thin, making it especially susceptible to irritation and sensitivity.

Dr. Green also notes that you can develop a skin allergy at any age. In fact, developing a sudden allergy to metals used in earrings and other jewelry is incredibly common, even after repeated exposure. So if your favorite pair of earrings is suddenly causing you discomfort, it’s quite common.

Can you find out the metals to which you’re allergic?

If you’re finding that some earrings cause irritation, make an appointment with a board-certified dermatologist who can perform a patch test to identify the offending allergens. The process is rather straightforward, explains Dr. Green. “A patch test applies the allergens to the skin with specific patches and are worn for a period of 48 hours. If there is a positive patch test, there will be skin irritation where the patch was placed, indicating a potential allergic reaction.” Once you’ve identified the materials that are causing an allergic reaction, you can avoid items containing that material.

Can sensitive ears become problematic?

If you’ve thought about trying to tough out any discomfort, you may want to think twice. Though you may only experience itching, redness, dryness or flaking, or a rash now, Dr. Green cautions that symptoms can progress and result in the formation of blisters or infection. “The irritated area of skin may start to feel warm to the touch, become filled with pus, or you may notice the rash is spreading,” Dr. Green says. If that happens, see your doctor to treat the infection and soothe any discomfort.

How do you choose earrings when you have sensitive ears?

Pay extra attention to the materials used in your earrings. If you have sensitive lobes, Dr. Green recommends avoiding nickel in particular, and being cautious with sterling silver and vermeil (gold-plated jewelry over sterling silver). Gold can be okay, but opt for 24-karat gold if possible since it’s the most pure.

The safest material for earrings if you’re sensitive is hypoallergenic titanium, a metal that is strong and durable enough for use in jewelry and also gentle enough that it won’t cause skin irritation. Medical grade plastic is another option for people with sensitive ears, as well as for children, says Dr. Green.

The best earrings for sensitive ears

Datenight HoopsVia Tinilux.com

Date Night hoops

Tini Lux was founded to meet the needs of people with sensitive ears. All of their earrings are made with pure, medical grade titanium as their base metal. We love these crystal hoops, which are made with biocompatible titanium that is not only safe for sensitive ears but also water-resistant and won’t tarnish, so you can wear them 24/7.

Shop Now

Safety Pin EarringsVia Baublebar.com

18-karat safety pin earrings

All of Baublebar’s jewelry is hypoallergenic and certified nickel-free, lead-free, cadmium-free, and phthalate-free. That makes us feel good about wearing these delicate safety pin earrings, which are 18-karat gold-plated sterling silver. In case you’re wondering whether or not they’re truly hypoallergenic, our tester wore these earrings every day for a week and had no reaction.

Shop Now

Beaded HoopsVia Onequince.com

14-karat gold beaded hoops

Did you know that Quince, the makers of the famous $50 cashmere sweater also make affordable gold jewelry? Well, you do now. These casual beaded hoops are made of pure, 14-karat yellow gold and are perfect for everyday wear and pairing with sweaters and dresses. The brand offers a 365-day free return policy, giving you even more peace of mind.

Shop Now

Dangly EarringsVia GemInAShell/Etsy.com

Charcoal Gray hypoallergenic earrings

Finding plastic earrings that aren’t designed for kids is no easy feat. Unless you head over to Etsy, that is. These dangling earrings have a gray glass crystal that is secured to a plastic hook with titanium or stainless steel wire.

Shop Now

Moon StudsVia Mejuri.com

Moon studs

These solid 14-karat gold studs, by delicate jewelry specialists Mejuri, are perfect for individual wear or pairing with your favorite hoops. The brand also sells a set of star studs, so don’t be shy about wearing a moon in one ear and a star in the other. Cute!

Shop Now

Ball StudsVia Auratenewyork.com

Gold ball studs

Sometimes less is more. These understated gold ball studs come in 14-karat white, yellow, or rose gold, and are perfect on their own or stacked with other earrings.

Shop Now

Cartilage Gold HoopVia Maisonmiru.com

Goddess cartilage hoop

Mason Miru jewelry is known for being nickel-free. This beaded cartilage hoop is made with implant grade titanium and can be worn in your tragus, helix, or earlobes as well as in your cartilage. Note that this hoop is sold as a single earring, so be sure to add two to your cart if want a pair.

Shop Now

Four Leaf Clover EarringsVia Zales.com

Four Leaf Clover hoop earrings

Looking for a bit of luck? You’ve found it. These four leaf clover hoop earrings are made with solid 14-karat yellow gold, yet are lightweight enough to wear all day long.

Shop Now

Pearl Drop EarringsVia Macys.com

Cultured Freshwater Pearl earrings

If you’re looking to dress up, it doesn’t get any more elegant than pearls. These drop earrings are made with 10K yellow or white gold and feature a cultured, freshwater pearl along with Sdiamond accents.

Shop Now

Sources:

Marisa Hillman
Marisa is a freelance writer and product expert covering product reviews, gift guides, and sales for RD.com. She is a former educator turned professional shopper dedicated to finding the best sales and products on the market. When she's not on deadline, she can be found exploring the East Coast or curled up at home with her nose in a book. She lives in New England with her husband, three children, and two dogs.